Hong Kong, over 100,000 people protesting on Sunday against a proposed law that would allow criminal suspects to be extradited to mainland China. Protestors carried along with the yellow umbrellas, harkening back to 2014 protests for democracy. Many in opposition to the proposed plan cite an increasing presence of mainland China as an area of great contention. They see having trials set in mainland China as void of human rights protections and the plan closing the gap between it and Hong Kong that derives from the relationship illustrated by the popular sentiment, “one country, two systems”.
Former legislator Leung Kwok-hung expressed disapproval for the plan saying those suspected of crimes “would need to face an unjust legal system on the mainland.” The proposed plan will allow for extraditions to not only mainland China, but Taiwan and Macau as well, increasing the number of countries Hong Kong has these treaties with. Those in support of the plan make the case that all extraditions can be challenged and either approved or denied by a Hong Kong appointed board. Furthermore, nobody at risk of the death penalty or torture is allowed to be extradited. In addition to these stipulations, many businesses have successfully bargained for nine commercial crimes to be exempt from extradition. While the plan has yet to be passed through the legislature, it has nonetheless brought attention, yet again, to mainland China’s growing influence looming over Hong Kong.
Huge Protest in Hong Kong against Chinese extradition plan
Tens of thousands of people have marched on Hong Kong’s parliament in opposition to proposed extradition rules that would allow criminal suspects to be sent to mainland China for trial.
Many of those taking part in Sunday’s protest carried yellow umbrellas, recalling Hong Kong’s massive 2014 pro-democracy protests, the leaders of which have been sentenced to up to 16 months in prison.
Opponents of the proposal fear a further erosion of rights and legal protections, which were guaranteed under the city’s handover from British colonial rule to Chinese sovereignty in 1997.
Participants marched peacefully for more than three hours through the shopping and business districts of Causeway Bay and Wanchai, with thousands staying on into the evening outside the Legislative Council and government headquarters.
Police said 22,800 people marched at the peak of the procession, but organisers estimated that 130,000 turned out – making it one of the largest street protests in the city for several years.
Observers said the turnout dwarfed an earlier protest against the plan last month.
Demonstrators carried placards accusing Hong Kong leader Carrie Lam of “selling out” Hong Kong and called on her to resign.
Some protesters dressed as Chinese mainland police officers guarding another demonstrator standing behind a portable red cage. One held up a sign that said: “President Xi Jinping, no legalised kidnapping of Hong Kong people to China”.
Leung Kwok-hung, a veteran activist and former legislator, said the government’s move risked removing Hong Kongers’ “freedom from fear”.
“Hong Kong people and visitors passing by Hong Kong will lose their right not to be extradited into mainland China,” he said. “They would need to face an unjust legal system on the mainland.”
Roland Lo, a 49-year-old protester, said Hong Kong and China have “completely different legal systems”.
“Creating a loophole that could mean a Hong Kong person gets extradited to China to face prosecution there, that completely destroys the guarantee of human rights and legal protection of one country, two systems.”
Lam and other government officials are standing fast by their proposals, calling them vital to plugging long-standing loopholes.
Under the changes, the Hong Kong leader would have the right to order the extradition of wanted offenders to China, Macau and Taiwan as well as other countries not covered by Hong Kong’s existing extradition treaties.
As a safeguard, such orders – to be issued case-by-case – can be challenged and appealed through the city’s independent legal system. Government officials have said no one at risk of the death penalty or torture or facing a political charge can be sent from Hong Kong.
The proposals could be passed into law later in the year, with the city’s pro-democratic camp no longer holding enough seats to block the move.
The government justified the swift introduction of the changes by saying they are needed so a young Hong Kong man suspected of murdering his girlfriend in Taiwan can be extradited to face charges there.
Under pressure from local business groups, they earlier exempted nine commercial crimes from the new provisions.
Sunday’s march comes amid renewed calls for deeper electoral reforms stalled five years ago after the Occupy Central protests.
Four leaders of the movement were last week sentenced to jail terms ranging from eight to 16 months, part of a group of nine activists found guilty after a near month-long trial.
Source: Al Jazeera, No bylines, Apr. 28, 2019. Photo credit to Tyrone Sui/Reuters.