The European Union has recently expressed concerns regarding “citizenship for sale” programs initiated by some EU member states, specifically Malta and Cyprus. Malta’s “citizenship for sale” program permits individuals to become citizens if they donate at least €650,000 to Malta’s development fund, purchase or lease property in the country, and invest at least €150,000 in Maltese stocks and bonds. Furthermore, family of individuals who satisfy these requirements can also become Maltese citizens if they pay a fee between €25,000 and €50,000. Obtaining citizenship from any EU state, such as Malta, affords these individuals the ability to work, live, and travel freely throughout any EU states included in the Schengen area.
The EU commissioner for justice, Vera Jourova, exclaimed to the Financial Times the EU’s intentions to further scrutinize states such as Malta and Cyprus for these citizenship programs. Although EU member states can independently promulgate rules for obtaining citizenship within their state, the EU has concerns regarding potential money laundering schemes by wealthy Russian citizens applying for citizenship in Malta and Cyprus. Although the EU commission for justice cannot make a binding rule banning the citizenship for sale programs, it is expected to publish a report highlighting the need for these countries to exhibit more due diligence when investigating citizenship applicants and the origins of their wealth. Additionally, the EU commission is considering updating its list of blacklisted countries who are at a high risk of money laundering because of the citizenship for sale programs.
EU Prepares Crackdown on ‘Citizenships for Sale’
Brussels is preparing to crack down on EU governments, including Malta and Cyprus, that award citizenships to rich people from outside the bloc, as concerns mount about so-called dirty money from Russia.
Vera Jourova, the EU’s commissioner for justice, told the Financial Times that “citizenship for sale” schemes in eight member states will come under tougher scrutiny from Brussels as part of a wider drive against money laundering and corruption.
She also alluded to worries about the origins of the wealth of Russian applicants for Maltese citizenship.
“In cases of any doubt, a person should not have the privilege of citizenship,” Ms Jourova told the Financial Times. “We have no power to ban such a practice but we have an obligation to put high requirements on the member states to be careful. They are granting citizenship for the whole of Europe.”
The EU states with “citizenship by investment” schemes include not only Malta and Cyprus, but also Austria, Greece, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania and Portugal.
Such schemes can require applicants to make substantial investments in property or bonds. In return they allow the new passport holders to work and live in any EU country and to travel freely inside the Schengen area.
EU member states are free to set their own criteria for citizenship. But the commission will publish a report in the autumn that is likely to fault government schemes for not carrying out enough due diligence on applicants and the sources of their wealth.
The report is part of the more general drive against money laundering, in conjunction with the European Central Bank and the European Banking Authority, which is intended to strengthen provisions against illicit cash.
High-profile money laundering scandals involving banks in Malta and Latvia have made citizenship schemes more contentious by drawing attention to the lack of controls on Russian funds entering EU countries.
Ms Jourova said she was especially alarmed by Malta’s scheme, in which an individual can gain citizenship in return for a €650,000 contribution to the country’s development fund and the purchase or lease of property, as well as investments of at least €150,000 in stocks and bonds.
Family members can be added for an additional fee of €25,000 to €50,000 per person.
“It is a big concern when a Russian citizen who has worked his whole life in middle or senior management — where salaries aren’t very high — suddenly has the money to buy citizenship in Malta,” the commissioner said.
Malta’s scheme, put in place in 2014, has brought €590m to the country from more than 700 investors, according to Identity Malta, the government body that runs the programme.
The Maltese government has begun to publish the names of individuals granted citizenship. In 2016, the list included Boris Mints, the Russian billionaire owner of investment company O1 Group, and Arkady Volozh, the founder of Yandex, Russia’s biggest search engine.
In March, a report by Transparency International with the Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project found the passport schemes posed a “major corruption risk” to the EU.
Ms Jourova said: “We want the states to do their due diligence and not to enable criminals to come to Europe and have equal rights as people who came years ago, who work, who pay taxes and have children and have to wait for citizenship.”
Golden visas represent only a small proportion of new EU passports. In 2016, 994,800 citizenship applicants were granted across the EU, according to Eurostat, with just 0.1 per cent of applications made under investment schemes.
The Investment Migration Council, the industry body that represents investors and governments who take part in the schemes, insists the most popular programmes — in Austria, Malta, and Cyprus — pose no security threat to Europe.
“Significant time and capital is spent by professional firms and governments to ensure the tightest levels of security and background checks are carried out by European and global security agencies,” said Dimitry Kochenov, chairman of the IMC.
Ms Jourova said the commission would also work faster in updating its blacklist of countries that have a high risk of money laundering. Russia is not on the list at present.
Source: The Financial Times, Mehreen Khan, August 12, 2018. Photo credit to Reuters.